So bad they win

Who’s the first worst?


Here’s the sad, hidden truth about journalism: All too often, terrible stories are written by talented reporters.

Did these reporters interview only one source? Was that source wrong on the facts? Did they forget to check those facts? Did they violate damn near every entry in the SPJ Code of Ethics?

Those reporters might be evil. Or they might be tired.

Last year, I met a journalist at a major gaming news outlet. He hated half of everything he wrote – because he was under pressure from his bosses to churn out 5-10 posts a day.

So there’s a fair chance the winner of the first-ever Kunkel Award for Worst Story of the Year won’t dispute receiving this dubious honor.

Of course, it’s just as likely it goes to someone who doesn’t give a shit about being ethical.

Either way, I’ve been asked why the Kunkels are offering such an inflammatory award. It’s not like most gaming journalists respect us in the first place. Won’t this just make it worse?

Maybe. But the Kunkel Awards seek to improve gaming journalism by teaching both readers and reporters what’s excellent. That’s why we insist on blunt judges’ comments.

Sometimes, though, you learn best by knowing what not to do.

The goal here isn’t humiliation. It’s education. So this is the only Kunkel Award that comes with a prize: A free year of SPJ membership.

Let the jokes about that begin.

Tomorrow: The Kunkels go to college.


Nominate your favorite gaming stories and videos of 2016

 


Defending the First Amendment and promoting open government are more crucial now than ever. Join SPJ's fight for the public’s right to know — either as an SPJ Supporter or a professional, student or retired journalist.


62 Responses to “So bad they win”

  1. J.G. Says:

    There is a real good chance for Kotaku to pick up another price this year it seems 😉

  2. JoeSislack Says:

    They got serious competition from places like Polygon or Destructoid or others to say the least.

  3. Michael Koretzky Says:

    I’m not a Kunkel judge, but I agreed with them: Kotaku kicked ass last year in the news category. Sorry.

  4. Meittimies Says:

    Your “misbehaving child should be awarded with candy!”-approach didnt really help make journalism better,huh? Gee, who would have guessed that? SPJ seriously needs some Gordon Ramsays of its own to just bluntly tell terrible journalists how terrible they are and why.

    Who is ever going to take your ethical guidelines seriously if theres nobody enforcing them? This year especially showed that bad journalists should be humiliated and hated even more. To drive the point across their bad behaviour is not tolerated and denies them the right to call themselves journalists.

  5. Michael Koretzky Says:

    I dunno, journalists get bluntly told they’re terrible all the time. You can only beat a mule so much before it figures there’s no sense in listening at all.

  6. Billy Says:

    Twitter blockbots have made it a little difficult to beat the mule.

  7. Meittimies Says:

    Then you beat it dead and replace it. If they refuse to become better, then they should be smoked out of the profession by shaming them. This happens with all other professions from catering services to carpentry where the reputation of being bad at your job can ruin your career, why should journalists be exempt from that?

    Rewarding bad quality and bad behaviour takes the pride away from the profession and erodes the overall quality of the profession as a whole. You have to affect the livelihoods of these bad journalists to make them understand they cant get away with their unethical crap any longer.

    One of the reasons why US journalismis as bad as it is, because SpJ itself treats bad apples with silk gloves. Not much hope for the state of journalism if their very own community is such a tight circle-jerk they cant critisize and chastise each other anymore.

  8. Michael Koretzky Says:

    1. Let’s be clear: Most journalists don’t suck, and they don’t cover national issues. They toil locally, exposing city and county corruption.

    2. Of those who do suck, some are overworked, others are under-trained, and an unknown quantity are raging assholes. I’m not prepared to flay the skin off the first two groups just because the third piss me off.

    3. SPJ could lean harder, I guess, but read the ethics blog (http://blogs.spjnetwork.org/ethics/) and I think we call out loser more than, say, the AMA calls out doctors or the Bar Association calls out lawyers.

    4. A “tight circle-jerk” is not appealing. It’s one of those times when you crave personal space.

  9. Meittimies Says:

    1. Thats not an excuse for the more visible bad apples misbehaviour, or the lack of self-criticism in journalist circles. Rule 1. is true here in my home country because we have higher standards, US journos are generally a walking joke in comparison.

    2. Those excuses do not fly in any other profession, why does overworking and lacking education excuse bad behaviour solely in journalism?

    3. You have to get statistics on that because right now it seems SPJ protects the bad apples more than it chastises them. I understand SPJs power is limited but even a simple Hall of Fame and Hall of Shame can do wonders. Yet SPJ seems to be afraid of openly calling out the bad apples and lets the rot fester the whole profession.

    Whether its because you’re complacent, lazy or youre in bed with the bad apples, the result is the same: You have no pride or sense of “craftsmanship” in your work, and as a result we get historically low trust on US media. if none of you give a shit about your work, why should the readers?

    4. Yet most US journalists have turned their working places into a temple of self-gratification where they masturbate each other off day in and day out. The fact most of you put the narrative before actual news is proof of that. If the mainstream media is doing as badly as it is doing this year, theres even less hope for the gaming media.

    You have enormous problems with the trust of the media so hard measures are absolutely necessary to fix it. If you keep treating the fake journalists with silk gloves, then thats a message for the bad apples that they can get away with their bad behaviour and continue doing it, while the public trust on all journalists dwindle because they dont seem to give a crap about their own jobs anymore.

    If your peers ever wonder what normal people think of their profession, there it is. Read this post out loud to them. Its the painful truth theyre in denial from.

  10. The Nooseflex Says:

    Frustrating isn’t it?

  11. วิธีสมัคร fun88 Says:

    วิธีสมัคร fun88

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  12. skate Says:

    skate

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  13. https://yourdomain.com Says:

    https://yourdomain.com

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  14. joker gaming Says:

    joker gaming

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  15. ecommerce Says:

    ecommerce

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  16. Suggested Browsing Says:

    Suggested Browsing

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  17. Highly recommended Web-site Says:

    Highly recommended Web-site

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  18. online store Says:

    online store

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  19. pop over here Says:

    pop over here

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  20. why not check here Says:

    why not check here

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  21. click here Says:

    click here

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  22. gb wa Says:

    gb wa

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  23. click through the next article Says:

    click through the next article

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  24. fun88 คา สิ โน Says:

    fun88 คา สิ โน

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  25. gb whatsapp Says:

    gb whatsapp

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  26. fun88 thai Says:

    fun88 thai

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  27. https://nnetw.org/ Says:

    https://nnetw.org/

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  28. สมัคร fun888 Says:

    สมัคร fun888

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  29. SPJ Kunkel Awards Says:

    Hoa Mcclintic

    I found a great…

  30. SPJ Kunkel Awards Says:

    Randi Anctil

    I found a great…

  31. SPJ Kunkel Awards Says:

    Art Mell

    I found a great…

  32. good personal narrative stories Says:

    good personal narrative stories

    blog topic

  33. SPJ Kunkel Awards Says:

    Ozell Isaiah

    I found a great…

  34. วิธีสมัครfun88 Says:

    วิธีสมัครfun88

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  35. fun88 casino Says:

    fun88 casino

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  36. tode Says:

    tode

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  37. fun88 ทางเข้า วันนี้ ฟรี Says:

    fun88 ทางเข้า วันนี้ ฟรี

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  38. more about Gamewin 88slot Blogspot Says:

    more about Gamewin 88slot Blogspot

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  39. onengbet Says:

    onengbet

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  40. link webpage Says:

    link webpage

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  41. hk toto Says:

    hk toto

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  42. togel win 88 Says:

    togel win 88

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  43. gamewin88 Says:

    gamewin88

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  44. www.megavideomerlino.com Says:

    http://www.megavideomerlino.com

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  45. simply click the next site Says:

    simply click the next site

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  46. sneak a peek here Says:

    sneak a peek here

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  47. via Gamewin 88idnlive Blogspot Says:

    via Gamewin 88idnlive Blogspot

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  48. agen togel asia Says:

    agen togel asia

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  49. onengbet link alternatif Says:

    onengbet link alternatif

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  50. Discover More Says:

    Discover More

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  51. ฟัน88 Says:

    ฟัน88

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  52. kyle buys houses Says:

    kyle buys houses

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  53. watch movies online site Says:

    watch movies online site

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  54. fun88 ทางเข้าล่าสุด Says:

    fun88 ทางเข้าล่าสุด

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  55. click the next internet site Says:

    click the next internet site

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  56. dunialeague Says:

    dunialeague

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  57. assyfa.my.id Says:

    assyfa.my.id

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  58. hop over to these guys Says:

    hop over to these guys

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  59. use www.newlivecode.info here Says:

    use http://www.newlivecode.info here

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  60. www.oakleysunglasseseyeglasses.us.com Says:

    http://www.oakleysunglasseseyeglasses.us.com

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  61. My Web Site Says:

    My Web Site

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

  62. his comment is here Says:

    his comment is here

    SPJ Kunkel Awards » Blog Archive » So bad they win | A Society of Professional Journalists Blog

Leave a Reply

Connect

Twitter Facebook Google Plus RSS Instagram Pinterest Pinterest LinkedIn


© Society of Professional Journalists. All rights reserved. Legal

Society of Professional Journalists
P.O. Box 441748, Indianapolis, IN 46244
317/927-8000 | Fax: 317/920-4789
Contact SPJ Headquarters | Employment Opportunities | Advertise with SPJ