What really matters

Gideon Grudo and Tyler Krome

Black Lives Matter doesn’t matter this much.

At Wesleyan University in Middletown, Connecticut, the private liberal arts school is in the middle of a very public controversy.

Last week, the student newspaper ran a column called Why Black Lives Matter Isn’t What You Think. Written by staff writer Bryan Stascavage, it opined…

It boils down to this for me: If vilification and denigration of the police force continues to be a significant portion of Black Lives Matter’s message, then I will not support the movement, I cannot support the movement. And many Americans feel the same. I should repeat, I do support many of the efforts by the more moderate activists.

Stascavage ended with…

At some point Black Lives Matter is going to be confronted with an uncomfortable question, if they haven’t already begun asking it: Is this all worth it? Is it worth another riot that destroys a downtown district? Another death, another massacre? At what point will Black Lives Matter go back to the drawing table and rethink how they are approaching the problem?

In the days since, Wesleyan activists with Black Lives Matter have done a lot more than write a letter to the editor. The Boston Globe has reported, “Wesleyan students want to shut down their own newspaper for its Black Lives Matter coverage.”

The Chronicle of Higher Education added that slightly less reactionary students are demanding, “space on the newspaper’s front page should be devoted to submissions from minority voices.”

That led Argus editors to post a staff editorial apologizing for “our carelessness in fact-checking. The op-ed cites inaccurate statistics and twists facts.” However, they didn’t list those stats and facts. They also apologized “for the distress the piece caused the student body.”

This entire mess distresses Frank LoMonte. He’s executive director of the Student Press Law Center.

“It’s totally legitimate for them to protest the paper if they feel ill-served,” LoMonte says of the Black Lives Matter students. “But it goes too far to insist that every issue set aside front-page space for a minority-perspective or to threaten the paper’s funding.”

LoMonte continues….

Obviously, a private college isn’t legally obliged to continue funding the paper, but it would set a terribly intimidating precedent if making readers mad resulted in being de-funded. Would the readers really be better served by no newspaper at all? Obviously not. If the dissenters want to come up with a better newspaper, great, they can apply for funding and compete in the marketplace.

LoMonte’s days are spent defending student journalists from censorious administrators. In this twisted case, he’s defending students from students – and he has Wesleyan administrators on his side.

“Debates can raise intense emotions, but that doesn’t mean that we should demand ideological conformity because people are made uncomfortable,” wrote Wesleyan president Michael Roth. “We certainly have no right to harass people because we don’t like their views. Censorship diminishes true diversity of thinking.”

Attention Wesleyan Black Lives Matter: You know you’ve lost your campus’s hearts and minds when frequent enemies are aligned against you. Even worse, you know you’re toast when Gawker makes fun of you with “lmao.”

As an SPJ national director, I’ve emailed the shell-shocked Argus editors, offering to help them any way I can. But since everyone is piling on the student protesters, I want to make them this public offer…

If Wesleyan’s Black Lives Matter will stop trying to shut down their student newspaper, I’ll help them start their own. 

As LoMonte says, media can “compete in the marketplace.” I’ll help raise money for web and print publishing, and I’ll  assist with all the boring logistics so the students who hate The Argus can create a media outlet they like.

This isn’t a shtick, ploy, scheme, or bluff. The last time I offered to help students start their own publication, they raised more than $5,000. I truly believe anyone who commits an act of journalism not only informs their readers but also themselves. That’s my only greedy self-interest.

So all it takes is this: Any of 147 students who signed the Wesleyan petition complaining The Argus “neglects to provide a safe space for the voices of students of color,” I’ll help you create that safe space. But you have to maintain it. I hope that matters enough for you to email me.

Defending the First Amendment and promoting open government are more crucial now than ever. Join SPJ's fight for the public’s right to know — either as an SPJ Supporter or a professional, student or retired journalist.

  • Mark Samenfink

    I hate how completely expected this series of events is. I had no surprises in this article.
    By the way, good on you Koretzky, being proactive to defend editorial freedom.

  • AndySchotz

    The petition asks for things that might be reasonable, for all campus groups, such as diversity training, and other things that are not, such as dictating what must be on the newspaper’s front page. That distinction is important – what the university expects of student groups vs. the need for editorial freedom.

    If a newspaper doesn’t serve the campus, it’s fair for a group to try to start another one. Competition usually is good for any community.

    But it’s not clear if there was anything wrong at Wesleyan other than dissatisfaction with a pointed op/ed piece. There was a protest, and the newspaper has promised changes (maybe going too far) to address the concerns.

    If any group is not satisfied with the newspaper, why not join and make it better rather than trying to silence it?

  • sungardensoul

    That led Argus editors to post a staff editorial apologizing for “our carelessness in fact-checking. The op-ed cites inaccurate statistics and twists facts.” However, they didn’t list those stats and facts. They also apologized “for the distress the piece caused the student body.”

    SO Mr. Koretzky, what exactly are the facts? If you are going to report this story accurately then the most important thing you can do is to get to the facts. You waste all these paragraphs on bullshit about another paper to compete with The Argus which is probably a long standing rock solid tradition (oo oo $5000) This is a joke.

    You have not addressed the issue anymore than the staff editorial did in their completely inadequate apology. It reminds me of the movie Blow Up when the photograph of the gun was blown up so big you couldn’t recognize the gun.

    Shoddy journalism, about shoddy journalism, upon shoddy journalism. This is what the public gets. Shame on all of you for calling yourself journalists.

  • Michael Koretzky

    I’m not an investigative reporter on this story. I’m an SPJ board member who gets queasy at calls to shutter media outlets, so I’m offering student protesters something to do besides protesting.

    As I wrote, if The Argus wants my help, I’m there. (They have yet to ask.) And if Black Lives Matter wants to dabble in some journalism, I’m there. (Haven’t heard back, sadly.)

    That’s all I intended with my “paragraphs on bullshit.”

    And yes, I call myself a journalist. And yes, I have no shame.

  • sungardensoul

    so what really matters, to you, is journalism? no one said you have to be an investigative reporter to discuss this problem at The Argus intelligently, hey you don’t even have to google for the missing stats to give a professional response to student journalists who are trying to publish a newspaper

    a poet friend of mine got the point across about why activists have to spell it out that their lives matter, in a way that would keep others from countering by missing the entire point saying WE matter too

    instead of “Black Lives Matter” they could say “Let Us Go Home”

    starting a newspaper is not going to get them home, the criminal justice system traps black lives and fails them at every step in the process until they flat out can’t go home, either because they’re dead or they’re in jail

    grow up Koretzky, if you’re going to speak to young adults at least show some respect for their struggles to negotiate their way through the complete mess that immature adults have made of their lives, and that includes the poor ignorant kid who wrote the editorial that started the controversy, maybe him most of all, since he may perhaps be ambitious to become a journalist, unlike the activists you’re trying to recruit

    not a helpful blog this which you dare to call What Really Matters.

  • Pingback: king county real estate()

  • Pingback: Hack 2015()

  • I’m not powerful enough to change U.S. policing tactics. I’ve got just enough juice to help students learn through media, so that’s what I’m doing. I intend no disrespect, although I concede I’ve never really grown up.

  • Higher education is the key to lift people into great careers like court reporting. http://www.martelelectronics.com


Twitter Facebook Google Plus RSS Instagram Pinterest Pinterest LinkedIn

© Society of Professional Journalists. All rights reserved. Legal

Society of Professional Journalists
Eugene S. Pulliam National Journalism Center, 3909 N. Meridian St., Indianapolis, IN 46208
317/927-8000 | Fax: 317/920-4789 | Contact SPJ Headquarters | Employment Opportunities | Advertise with SPJ