When is a picture too much?

By Andrew M. Seaman

One of the last moments of Ki Suk Han’s life was broadcast to the world on the cover of Tuesday’s New York Post.

The 58-year-old Queens man was pushed in front of an oncoming Q train in New York City’s subway system on Monday. On the cover, Han is shown clinging to the subway platform seconds before being pinned between it and the cars, according to the Post’s description of events. He later died of his injuries.

The front page caught the attention of several journalists, whose Twitter reactions and judgments were nicely curated by Poynter’s Jeff Sonderman.

“Grim,” “sickening” and “over the line” were all used to describe the Post’s front page.

SPJ’s own Kevin Smith, chair of the Ethics Committee, wrote in a tweet that the Post’s decision showed an “astounding lack of ethics.”

Indeed, the SPJ Code of Ethics is clear that journalists should minimize harm by showing good taste and not pandering to lurid curiosity.

Unlike gut-wrenching pictures that show the human toll of wars or the devastating impact of natural disasters, the photo of Han on the Post’s cover does not add to the public discourse. The picture tells us nothing more than Han was most likely terrified in the last moments of his conscious life.

This is not the fault of the photographer – R. Umar Abbasi – who is now facing public backlash and questions about whether he could have done more to save Han. Like many of the photographers asked by Gawker, I don’t have enough information to weigh in on that argument.

Blame, however, does fall on the editors of the Post, who had time to make the decision to publish the image on the cover – with an oversized “DOOMED” splashed across the bottom.

A quick look at the paper’s website shows that there are other photographs the Post could have used, including exteriors of the subway station and a waiting ambulance. Though they may not be as jarring as the image of Han about to be hit by a train, those pictures are more respectful toward him and his family – another lesson from the Code of Ethics.

In this case, the damage has been done. Others reproduced, linked, tweeted, blogged and disseminated the cover throughout the world.

Perhaps the best we can hope for is that the Post and other news organizations will learn from the ample public backlash brought on by this cover.

Email this to someoneTweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+Share on FacebookShare on TumblrShare on RedditPin on Pinterest

Unfettered access to those in power, a push for government transparency and a vigorous defense of the First Amendment are perhaps more important now than ever before. Join us as we fight for the public’s right to know as an SPJ Supporter. Or, if you’re a journalist, we welcome you to stand with us as a Professional, Student or Retired Member.


  • Richard Francis Gaspar

    Sometimes extreme administrative ignorance forces extreme distribution tactics. I just want to see the photos of Koretzky distributing the papers topless to keep the media attention equally distributed.

    Rick Gaspar
    Adviser, Hillsborough Community College

  • Annonymous

    FAU has a long history of trying to silence students and ignoring their needs. Respectable is not a word I would use to describe the leadership at this university.

  • Jonny

    Radical journalists that will do or say anything in the interest of attracting readers is shameful. While I do not support bigotry, the UP has a history of publishing crap in order to create a buzz. Not knowing the content of the SFGN I cannot comment on the particular decision, but I would support the universities decision to clean up on poor journalism, legal or not. Perhaps a group can organize in mass to follow around and take pictures and videos of some (hopefully) really great looking boobies, while all committing to not accept a single newspaper handed out.

  • Natalee Dane

    Pig…
    FAU’s actions still infringe on individual(s) Freedom of Speech

    oh & SFGN’s bold tactic is themed from one of their past articles

  • Annonymous

    SFGN is a great paper. I’m not gay but I love seeing it on campus. Makes me feel like the school’s a place that acknowledges the variety inherent in the student body. Then they get rid of it and I suddenly remember I attend FAU.

Connect

Twitter Facebook Google Plus RSS Instagram Pinterest Pinterest LinkedIn


© Society of Professional Journalists. All rights reserved. Legal

Society of Professional Journalists
Eugene S. Pulliam National Journalism Center, 3909 N. Meridian St., Indianapolis, IN 46208
317/927-8000 | Fax: 317/920-4789 | Contact SPJ Headquarters | Employment Opportunities | Advertise with SPJ